The Atlantic Monthly, Volume 08, No. 47, September, 1861 by Various
page 47 of 295 (15%)
page 47 of 295 (15%)
![]() | ![]() |
|
indicated by various other internal proofs to which attention has been
heretofore sufficiently directed.[mm] The punctuation, too, which, as Mr. Collier announced in "Notes and Emendations," etc., 1853, is corrected "with nicety and patience," is that of the books printed after the Restoration, as may be seen by a comparison of Mr. Collier's private fac-similes and the collations of "Hamlet" in Mr. Hamilton's book with the original editions of poems and plays printed between 1660 and 1675. [Footnote ll: Or 1663, according to the title-pages of some copies that we have seen.] [Footnote mm: See _Shakespeare's Scholar_, pp. 56-62. And to the passages noticed there, add this: In _King Henry VI_., Part II., Act IV., Sc. 5, is this couplet:-- "Fight for your King, your country, and your lives. And so farewell; for I must hence again." The last line of which in Mr. Collier's folio is changed to "And so farewell; _Rebellion never thrives_." Plainly this was written when Charlie was no longer over the water.] From the foregoing examination of the evidence upon this most interesting question, it appears, we venture to assume, that the conclusions drawn by Mr. Collier's opponents as to the existence of primal evidence of forgery in the ink writing alone in his folio are not sustained by the premises which are brought forward in their support. It seems also clear, that, to say the least, it is not safe to assume that |
|