Punch, or the London Charivari, Volume 153, November 14, 1917 by Various
page 51 of 52 (98%)
page 51 of 52 (98%)
![]() | ![]() |
|
this side the Atlantic. His farm-bred _Sadie_, a Buffalo shirt-packer,
classifies men by the sizes of their shirts, has no use for any swain with a chest measurement under forty, and eventually in a most original way finds her hero in _Mister 44_ (METHUEN), an enormous Canadian engineer and sportsman. She is no chicken herself and has a passion to be free of the city and out in the great open. _Sadie_ is more than big; she is beautiful, burnished-copper-haired, sincere and kind, and, though I think the author "gets this over" quite well I liked her best before she found her man and her _Robinson Crusoe_ adventures among the islands of Ontario, and was giving back chat to the little foreman in the factory. Here she is a pure delight; and in these days, when a knowledge of the American language may come in handy at any moment, this amiable romance may well be recommended as an attractive manual of first-aid in the matter. * * * * * Without professing to be a student of Mrs. DIVER'S books I know enough about them to be worried by the commonplaceness of _Unconquered_ (MURRAY). Like so many other authors she has succumbed to the lure of the War-novel. There may be a public for tales of this kind, but I have not yet read one that approaches artistic success. Here we are spared nothing. _Sir Mark Forsyth_ goes to France in the early days, is first of all reported "missing, believed killed," and then officially reported "killed." Of course he turns up again, but such a physical wreck that the minx whom he was to have married breaks off the engagement. Naturally the sweet girl, friend of _Mark's_ childhood, undertakes to fill the gap. The minx, _Bel Alison_, is so scathingly drawn that from sheer perversity I found myself hunting for one good point in her character; but without a find. On the other |
|