Punch, or the London Charivari, Volume 99, October 4, 1890 by Various
page 37 of 41 (90%)
page 37 of 41 (90%)
|
being suggestive of all this to the majority, the majority will be
disappointed when it doesn't get all that this very responsible title has led them to expect. Those who know the French novel will be dissatisfied with the English adaptation of it, filtered, as it has been, through a French dramatic version of the story. So much for the title. For the play itself, as given by Messrs. BUCHANAN and HORNER,--the latter of whom, true to ancestral tradition, will have his finger in the pie,--it is but an ordinary drama, strongly reminding a public which knows its DICKENS of the story of _Little Em'ly_, with _Vaillant_ for _Old Peggotty_, _Lydie_ for _Little Em'ly_, _Antonin Caussade_ for _Ham_, and _Paul Astier_ for _Steerforth_. Perhaps it would be carrying the resemblance too far to see in _Rosa Dartle_, with her scorn For "that sort of creature," the germ of _Esther de Sélény_. Mix this with a situation from _Le Monde où l'on s'ennuie_, spoilt in the mixing, and there's the drama. [Illustration: The Avenger.] For the acting--it is admirable. Miss GENEVIEVE WARD is superb as _Madame Paul Astier_, and it is not her fault, but the misfortune of the part, that the wife of _Paul_ is a woman old enough to be his mother, with whose sufferings--with her eyes wide open, having married a man of whose worthlessness she was aware,--it is impossible to feel very much sympathy. She is old enough to have known better. Mr. GEORGE ALEXANDER'S performance of the scoundrel _Paul_ leaves little to be desired, but he must struggle for dear life against his--of course, unconscious--imitation of HENRY IRVING. Shut your eyes to the facts, occasionally, especially in the death-scene, and it is the voice of IRVING; open them, and it is ALEXANDER agonising. No one can care for the fine lady, statuesquely impersonated by Miss ALMA STANLEY, who |
|