Elements of Debating by Leverett S. Lyon
page 17 of 168 (10%)
page 17 of 168 (10%)
![]() | ![]() |
|
force." He did not get very far on the way toward making his term
clear. Be sure that your definition really explains the term. Then one must be careful not to define in a circle. Let us take, for example, the assertion or proposition, "The development of labor unions has been beneficial to commerce." If you should attempt to define "development" by saying "development means growth," you would not have made the meaning of the term much clearer; and if in a further attempt to explain it, you could only add "And growth means development," you would be defining in a circle. There is still another error to be avoided in making your terms clear to your audience. This error is called begging the question. This occurs when a term is defined in such a way that there is nothing left to be argued. Suppose your friend should say to you: "I wish to make you believe that the honor system should be used in all examinations in the Greenburg High School." You ask him what he means by the "honor system." He replies: "I mean the best system in the world." Is there anything left to argue? Hardly, if his definition of the term honor system is correct, for it would be very irrational indeed to disagree with the assertion that the best system in the world should be adopted in the Greenburg High School. To summarize: _Define terms carefully;_ make the definition clear; do not define in a circle, and do not beg the question. As you have already noticed, terms in argumentation, such as "honor system," often consist of more than one word. They sometimes contain |
|