Judgments of the Court of Appeal of New Zealand on Proceedings to Review Aspects of the Report of the Royal Commission of Inquiry into the Mount Erebus Aircraft Disaster - C.A. 95/81 by Duncan Ivor L. M. Richardson R. B. Cooke Sir Owen Woodhouse;Wallace McMullin;Sir Edward Somers
page 100 of 115 (86%)
page 100 of 115 (86%)
|
During the first six days after the accident I was at the crash
site at all times when the site was occupied. In regard to evidence reported in the Christchurch Press today, 5 Dec 1980, I can state unequivocally that: (1) Captain Gemmell did not spend any time inspecting the aircraft without other people being present. (2) Captain Collins flight bag was found by me the day after the crash, this being three days before any Air N.Z. personnel or crash investigators reached the site. My recollection is that it was empty when I first inspected it. It certainly contained no diaries or briefing material. (3) Captain Gemmell did not remove any items from the persons of deceased lying in the area...." Counsel proceeded to read from the letter which goes on to refer to instructions concerning the crevassed area of the ice-slope. No challenge was made to the views expressed by Mr Woodford nor was he called to give evidence. And no evidence to any contrary effect was given by anybody. Yet apart from the passing reference to the matter in paragraph 349 of the Report the point of view Mr Woodford expressed seems to have been given no attention. The extent of the evidence which could have been given by Mr Woodford if he had been called as a witness is indicated by his affidavit now put before this Court. The importance of the letter seems obvious. The bag being empty when it was seen only 18 hours after the aircraft had crashed it is difficult to understand |
|