paragraph 347 of the Report):

"You've already given evidence and stated your qualification. I
think you have offered to give some supplementary evidence relating
to activity at the Erebus crash site ... Our discussion with Capt.
Eden last Friday indicated this would be appreciated.

I think just as Capt. Gemmell was there representing the co. you
were there as a rep. of ALPA.... Thats correct.

May we take it that you worked in conjunction with Capt. Gemmell
and other members of the team involved.... Correct.

And in so doing you were present at the crash site with Capt.
Gemmell.... No we had different tasks as I was in the area with
Capt. Gemmell at some stages.

So far as your observations are concerned what would you have to
say regarding Capt. Gemmell's conduct and behaviour in the course
of his duties there.... I have no reason to doubt Capt. Gemmell in
any way shape or form.

Have you ever suggested otherwise to anybody.... I have not."

Then he was cross-examined by counsel for the Association whose witness
he had been earlier. He was asked about Captain Gemmell's work at the
actual scene of the disaster and his explanation about that matter is
reflected in the following question and answer:

"Did you see Capt. Gemmell at any time in the cockpit area or