Adventures in Criticism by Sir Arthur Thomas Quiller-Couch
page 33 of 297 (11%)
page 33 of 297 (11%)
|
Or what but stark insensibility can explain the omission of "Take, O
take those lips away," and the bridal song "Roses, their sharp spines being gone," that opens _The Two Noble Kinsmen_? But stay: the Rev. Alexander Dyce may attribute this last pair to Fletcher. "Take, O take those lips away" certainly occurs (with a second and inferior stanza) in Fletcher's _The Bloody Brother_, first published in 1639; but Dyce gives no hint of his belief that Fletcher wrote it. We are, therefore, left to conclude that Dyce thought it unworthy of a place in his collection. On _The Two Noble Kinsmen_ (first published in 1634) Dyce is more explicit. In a footnote to the Memoir he says: "The title-page of the first edition of Fletcher's _Two Noble Kinsmen_ attributes the play partly to Shakespeare; I do not think our poet had any share in its composition; but I must add that Mr. C. Lamb (a great authority in such matters) inclines to a different opinion." When "Mr. C. Lamb" and the Rev. Alexander Dyce hold opposite opinions, it need not be difficult to choose. And surely, if internal evidence count for anything at all, the lines "Maiden pinks, of odour faint, Daisies smell-less, yet most quaint, And sweet thyme true." or-- "Oxlips in their cradles growing" or-- "Not an angel of the air, Bird melodious, or bird fair, |
|