An Account of the Proceedings on the Trial of Susan B. Anthony, on the Charge of Illegal Voting by Anonymous
page 67 of 270 (24%)
page 67 of 270 (24%)
![]() | ![]() |
|
This quotation by Hawkins is, I believe, from Bracton, which carries the principle back to a very early period in the existence of the common law. It is a principle, however, which underlies all law, and must have been recognized at all times, wherever criminal law has been administered, with even the slightest reference to the principles of common morality and justice. I quote again on this subject from Mr. Bishop: "The doctrine of _the intent_ as it prevails in the criminal law, is necessarily _one of the foundation principles of public justice_. There is only one criterion by which the guilt of man is to be tested. It is whether the mind is criminal. Criminal law relates only to crime. And neither in philosophical speculation, nor in religious or moral sentiment, would any people in any age allow that a man should be deemed guilty unless his mind was so. It is, therefore, a principle of our legal system, as probably it is of every other, that _the essence of an offence is the wrongful intent without which it cannot exist_." (_1 Bishop's Crim. Law, §287._) Again, the same author, writing on the subject of _knowledge_, as necessary to establish the intent, says: "It is absolutely necessary to constitute guilt, as in indictments for uttering forged tokens, or other attempts to defraud, or for receiving stolen goods, and offences of a similar description." (_1 Crim. Prac. §504._) In regard to the offence of obtaining property by false pretenses, the author says: "The indictment must allege that the defendant knew the pretenses to be false. _This is necessary upon the general principles of the law_, in order to show an offence, even though the statute does not |
|