might be added to. Especially when we come near to 1858 do the numbers
increase, and one of the most remarkable, as also most independent
champions of the evolution-idea before that date was Herbert Spencer, who
not only marshalled the arguments in a very forcible way in 1852, but
applied the formula in detail in his "Principles of Psychology" in 1855.
(See Edward Clodd, "Pioneers of Evolution", London, page 161, 1897.)

It is right and proper that we should shake ourselves free from all
creationist appreciations of Darwin, and that we should recognise the
services of pre-Darwinian evolutionists who helped to make the time ripe,
yet one cannot help feeling that the citation of them is apt to suggest two
fallacies. It may suggest that Darwin simply entered into the labours of
his predecessors, whereas, as a matter of fact, he knew very little about
them till after he had been for years at work. To write, as Samuel Butler
did, "Buffon planted, Erasmus Darwin and Lamarck watered, but it was Mr
Darwin who said 'That fruit is ripe,' and shook it into his lap"...seems to
us a quite misleading version of the facts of the case. The second fallacy
which the historical citation is a little apt to suggest is that the
filiation of ideas is a simple problem. On the contrary, the history of an
idea, like the pedigree of an organism, is often very intricate, and the
evolution of the evolution-idea is bound up with the whole progress of the
world. Thus in order to interpret Darwin's clear formulation of the idea
of organic evolution and his convincing presentation of it, we have to do
more than go back to his immediate predecessors, such as Buffon, Erasmus
Darwin, and Lamarck; we have to inquire into the acceptance of evolutionary
conceptions in regard to other orders of facts, such as the earth and the
solar system (See Chapter IX. "The Genetic View of Nature" in J.T. Merz's
"History of European Thought in the Nineteenth Century", Vol. 2, Edinburgh
and London, 1903.); we have to realise how the growing success of
scientific interpretation along other lines gave confidence to those who