Human Nature and Other Sermons by Joseph Butler
page 149 of 152 (98%)
page 149 of 152 (98%)
![]() | ![]() |
|
|
thought to their assistance. Any one of these, from various and
complicated reasons, may in particular cases prevail over the other two; and there are, I suppose, instances, where the bare SIGHT of distress, without our feeling any compassion for it, may be the occasion of either or both of the two latter perceptions. One might add that if there be really any such thing as the fiction or imagination of danger to ourselves from sight of the miseries of others, which Hobbes specks of, and which he has absurdly mistaken for the whole of compassion; if there be anything of this sort common to mankind, distinct from the reflection of reason, it would be a most remarkable instance of what was furthest from his thoughts--namely, of a mutual sympathy between each particular of the species, a fellow-feeling common to mankind. It would not indeed be an example of our substituting others for ourselves, but it would be an example of user substituting ourselves for others. And as it would not be an instance of benevolence, so neither would it be any instance of self-love: for this phantom of danger to ourselves, naturally rising to view upon sight of the distresses of others, would be no more an instance of love to ourselves than the pain of hunger is. {14} Ecclus. xxxii. 28. {15} Ecclus. xlii. 24. {16} Ver. 4, 5. {17} Ver. 6. {18} Micah vi. |
|


