Three Dialogues Between Hylas and Philonous by George Berkeley
page 37 of 139 (26%)
page 37 of 139 (26%)
![]() | ![]() |
|
obliges us to hold the same with regard to ABSOLUTE EXTENSION, which is
something abstracted from GREAT and SMALL, from this or that particular magnitude or figure. So likewise as to motion; SWIFT and SLOW are altogether relative to the succession of ideas in our own minds. But, it doth not follow, because those modifications of motion exist not without the mind, that therefore absolute motion abstracted from them doth not. PHIL. Pray what is it that distinguishes one motion, or one part of extension, from another? Is it not something sensible, as some degree of swiftness or slowness, some certain magnitude or figure peculiar to each? HYL. I think so. PHIL. These qualities, therefore, stripped of all sensible properties, are without all specific and numerical differences, as the schools call them. HYL. They are. PHIL. That is to say, they are extension in general, and motion in general. HYL. Let it be so. PHIL. But it is a universally received maxim that EVERYTHING WHICH EXISTS IS PARTICULAR. How then can motion in general, or extension in general, exist in any corporeal substance? HYL. I will take time to solve your difficulty. |
|