The Tattva-Muktavali by Purnananda Chakravartin
page 26 of 31 (83%)
page 26 of 31 (83%)
![]() | ![]() |
|
99. [I answer] A thorough Vedantin like thee does not accept any where the existence of qualities or that which possesses qualities; but if imagined qualities are done away with [by deeper insight], real qualities are nowhere done away with [Footnote: Clearer insight abolishes imagined attributes, as __e. g.__ the supposed snake in the rope; but real attributes remain untouched, and we hold Brahman's attributes to be real.--I read __abadha.h__ in I. 2.]. 100. If Brahman is understood to be destitute of qualities, then "truth," etc., will not be applicable to Him; but, if so, there arises a contradiction in such passages [of Sruti] as "he is the truthful," etc. [Footnote: I do not know where this passage occurs, but the kindred word __satyadharman__ is applied to several deities in the Rigveda.] 101. When the existence of such a thing as a quality is admitted, we can imagine it in something else [Footnote: The Vedantins hold that nothing exists besides Brahman; and yet, although they thus deny the existence of any other thing or quality, they hold that certain qualities are imagined to exist in him, forgetting that only one who has seen silver can imagine __rajatatva__ in nacre.]; but to imagine that nacre is silver, we must first know clearly what silver is. 102. This universe is based on the soul as its site, being imagined in it by ignorance; some teachers would describe it as an illusory emanation [Footnote: It is a favourite doctrine of the Vedanta that ignorance, as being imagined by ignorance, is itself false.]; but this is not a pleasing doctrine to me. |
|